Ian Buruma sememangnya penulis "terkenal"..tapi terkenal dikalangan puak-puak PKR je la..maybe sebab Ian Buruma adalah bukan Melayu dan bukan warganegara Malaysia...Dia dilahirkan kat The Hague, Belanda...bangsa penjajah jugak la ni...dia tak study pun pasal south east Asia sama ada pasal kebudayaan, adat resam, agama, cara pemikiran dan sebagainya...tiba-tiba je tulis pasal scenario politik Malaysia dan methodology beragama di Malaysia...tapi tak apa lah...tapi itukah penulis yang jadi kebanggaan Anwar? Pasal apa? Pasal dia puji Anwar la tu...nak tau profile Ian Buruma? Sila google sendiri...malas nak bagi "publisiti murahan" kat orang cam ni...buat cacat blog aku je...
Baru ni dia ada tulis article...tajuknya "The Malay Dilemma"...dengaq bunyi tajuk pun dah tahu dia nak tarik "publisiti murahan"...dia tiru tajuk buku Tun Dr. Mahathir dulu la tu...hehhehe...Tun M ditiru omputih...betapa hebatnya Tun bila omputih pun menirunya walaupun sekadar tajuk...nak tahu isinya? Panjang sangat article tu...malas nak copy paste...buat semak je...tapi, ada beberapa perenggan yang "elok diberi perhatian"....
Ian berkata :
Anwar — who had rebounded from six years in prison on corruption and sodomy charges to become the best hope for a more democratic, less corrupt Malaysia — speaks softly. He is still under constant surveillance, he said.
Saya kata:
Bagaimana Anwar menjadi harapan kepada demokrasi yang lebih baik dan Malaysia yang "kurang" corrupt? Sedangkan dia adalah bekas banduan yang dibuktikan bersalah mengamalkan corruption! Bukan setakat mahkamah sahaja yang menghukum dia sebegitu, malah kawan-kawan Anwar semasa dalam UMNO pun dok kuat bercerita betapa "bapak segala rasuahnya Anwar" tu...dan sekarang ni Anwar dok sebok ajaq PAS merasuah! Dah tu lagu mana yang nak kata Anwar tu "less corrupt"? Bapak rasuah ada laaaa....
Ian menulis lagi:
This was the same Anwar Ibrahim, one struggled to remember, who was once at the heart of the Malaysian establishment: the Minister of Culture in 1983, the Minister of Education in 1986, the Minister of Finance in 1991 and a Deputy Prime Minister in 1993. He was poised to succeed Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad. And then he got overconfident. Starting in the summer of 1997, when the Malaysian currency and stock market lost more than half of their value in the Asian financial meltdown, Anwar did something that Dr Mahathir found unforgivable.
Saya kata:
Anwar "gila" kat nak jual Malaysia kat IMF? Tu yang Tun M Marah time tu...yang tang "unforgivable" tu...elok tanya SB atau MIO...depa lebih tahu aktiviti Anwar time tu...tanyalah depa yang dah pencen dan takdak kepentingan pun...depa pun rasanya "tak dapat maafkan dosa-dosa Anwar"...dan sekarang satu dunia mengiktiraf tindakan Mohammad Nor Yaakob dan Tun M laksanakan...kaedah "tambatan RM"...tapi ada jugak puak2 PR yang dok claim bahawa Anwar yang buat kaedah tu! Depa tak tau ka yang Mohammad Nor Yaakub dan Tun M sendiri dok struggle tak tidoq malam 2-3 hari semata-mata berjegil mata nak cari jalan penyelesaian krisis matawang yang didalangi oleh kawan baik Anwar iaitu George Soros! Kawan baik dia buat "taik", lepas tu nak gadaikan Malaysia kat IMF...itulah tahap pemikiran Anwar!
Ian kata lagi:
Even as the prime minister was imposing capital controls and blaming “rogue speculators,” such as George Soros, for the crisis, Anwar launched an attack on “nepotism” and “cronyism” in his own party, Umno, which had been in power since independence. The “cronies” included members of Dr Mahathir’s family. While Dr Mahathir tried to bail out banks and corporations run by his allies, Anwar talked about transparency and accepting some of the International Monetary Fund’s recommendations for liberalising the economy.
Saya kata:
Nepotisme dan cronisme yang dilaungkan "Anwar" terhadap Tun...kenapa di zaman Pak Lah, Anwar sikit pun tak sentuh pasal KJ, budak-budak tingkat 4, geng-geng Pak Lah di media massa dan sebagainya? itu belum sentuh lagi soal Kamaluddin dan Patrick Badawi...kenapa dia tak attack Pak Lah? Pasal Pak Lah lepaskan dia dari penjara dan Pak Lah satu kampung dengan dia? Padahal Tun M sekat anak beranak dia join politik secara terang masa dia "diatas". Tanyalah veteran-veteran UMNO, berapa kali Tun M "cantas" nama Mokhzani, Mirzan malahan Mukhriz dari mencabur diri dalam kepimpinan UMNO. Rasanya Anwar lebih "melampau" cronism nya dengan menabur "pink form" kepada mereka-mereka yang menyokongnya untuk jadi Timbalan Presiden UMNO masa dia jadi Menteri Kewangannya...
Ian tulis:
Nobody was likely to miss the implication; Dr Mahathir has clearly stated his conviction that “Jews rule this world by proxy.” At the Hilton, Anwar, who started his career as the president of the Malaysian Muslim Students Union, and is a devout Muslim, shrugged. “They say I’m a Jewish agent, because of my friendship with Paul,” he said. “They also accuse me of being a lackey of the Chinese.” His eyebrows twitched in a gesture of disbelief, and he emitted a dry, barking laugh.
Saya kata:
Imam PKR ni tak baca Al-Quran ke? "Wa lan tardhau antumul yahudu wa lan nasara hatta tattabi'a millatahum". Mafhumnya "dan tidak akan sekali kali yahudi dan nasrani itu redha ke atas kamu semua sehinggalah kamu semua mengikut jalan (cara) mereka". TGNA pun pernah berkata : Berhati-hatilah apabila musuh kamu "bersetuju" dengan kamu. So? Hangpa semua judge la sendiri siapa Anwar...bila nak pilihanraya ke...by-election ke...ada je pertemuan dengan agent-agent Yahudi atau Singapore...duit la tu...takkan bagi duit saja kot? Nothing in "return" ke? Tulus ikhlas ke puak-puak yahudi ni bantu Anwar? Kalau ikhlas, sila rujuk firman Allah diatas...
Ian kata lagi:
To make sense of Anwar’s rise, fall, and rise, it helps to know something about the role of race and religion in Malaysia. The country’s population is more than half Malay, defined by ethnicity and the Muslim faith, but large numbers of Chinese (now about a quarter of the population) and Indians (seven per cent) arrived in the 19th century, when the British imported coolies from China and plantation workers from India. Tensions arising from this mélange — and, in particular, the fear held by Malays that they will always be bested by these minorities — have gripped Malaysian politics since the country achieved independence from the British, in 1957. In recent years, the situation has been further complicated by a surge in Islamic fervour among many Malays.
Saya kata:
Jadi, jatuh bangun Anwar selama ni yang menjadi ukuran rujukan Ian Buruma untuk judge tentang "role of race and religion in Malaysia"? Tak adil la kalau macam tu...patut pun "bias"! Berat sebelah! Mungkin itulah "keadilan" cara Ian Buruma dan Anwar dokong selama ni?
Ian tulis:
Lim was one of several people I spoke to in Malaysia who used the word “apartheid” in describing his country. “The ethnic situation has become much worse,” he said, especially since Malay nationalism took a strong Islamic turn in the late 1980s, when Umno was challenged by PAS. The Islamists got a boost from the Iranian Revolution, and actually took power in Kelantan in 1990. To preëmpt the Islamists, Umno, ostensibly a secular party, wedded its ethnic nationalism (which was decidedly not a feature of PAS) to religion: Muslims were no longer supposed to drink alcohol; women were encouraged to wear head scarves (tudung); easygoing Malay Islam took on the harsher tone of Wahhabi purism.
Saya kata:
Dasar "apartheid" pulak dahhh..."aparthied" menatang tang mana??? Late 1980s tu memang la kesedaran tentang Islam ni meningkat...maklum la...zaman tu Tun M yang mula memerintah...dalam kerajaan pun kesedaran Islamik tu semakin tinggi...masa tu parti koktel hidang arak pun dah takdak dah...seluaq pendek PT kaler putih pun dah ditukaq kepada seluaq panjang tutup aurat...dan budaya politik Iran dan Malaysia adalah berbeza, pasal apa pulak nak dijadikan bandingan? PAS memang bawa semangat ideologi revolusi, tapi depa bawa secara "sihat", tak dak similarity dengan dasar aparthied pun. Pakai tudung memang wajib dan minum arak adalah haram hukumnya, jadi salah tang mana? Itu dasar Wahabi ke? Imam Shafi'e pun menghukum lagu tu...tak semestinya Wahabi je...
Ian kata:
Meanwhile, in Lim’s view, educated Malays have been too timid to resist, whatever they might do or say in private. “I’ve seen it happening with my progressive university friends,” Lim said. “Wives take to wearing the tudung, the daughters cover up. Their passivity, their silence, is very bad for the community, because it allows the ultras to set the agenda. Islam has become more and more conservative. Muslims can no longer go to non-Malay restaurants or visit the houses of non-Malay friends. Tensions have grown. We’re reverting to the colonial situation, where the different races only meet in the marketplace.”
Saya kata:
Kepala hotak dia! Itu dah kira menghina Islam dan hukum hakamnya! Pakai tudung dikira wajib untuk menutup aurat! Menutup aurat tu wajib bagi umat Islam. Jadi, pasal apa nak prejudis terhadap tindakan wanita dan anak gadis kami yang pakai tudung untuk menutup aurat??? Passivity dan silence tu jadi threat untuk komuniti? Allows to the ultras to set agenda? kepala hotak dia la...bersangka buruk! Kami hanya menurut hukum agama kami! "lakum dinukum wa liya din"! Itu bukan "conservative, itu Islamic fundemantel! Sapa kata orang Islam tak boleh pi restaurant non-Malays? McDonald tu semua orang Islam punya ka? Dan sapa kata orang Islam tak boleh pi rumah non-Malays? Setiap kali Chinese New Year, Deepavali mahupun Chrismas, ramai je orang Islam yang menziarah rumah kawan-kawan depa yang non-Muslim...Jadi, Lim dan Ian ni sendiri yang cuba menyemai dasar "aparthied" kat Malaysia ni against Melayu Muslim! Ini boleh didakwa dibawah akta hasutan ni...
Ian menulis lagi:
Kelantan has hardly any huge buildings. Everything in the state capital, Kota Bharu, near the border with Thailand, is built on a modest scale. I met the PAS vice-president, Husam Musa, at the party headquarters. Husam, an economist by training, is not an imam but one of the new breed of professionals in Islamist politics. He was polite, if a little defensive. On the question of an Islamic state, he said this goal was often misunderstood: “We don’t mean a state ruled by clerics but one guided by the holy books. Without the books, we’d be like Umno and just grab the money. The difference between us and them is that we believe we will be judged in the afterlife.”
Saya kata:
Husam...apa ni Husam? Apa maknanya statement YB ni? Statement Husam ni bermakna ahli-ahli UMNO tak beriman kepada Hari Kiamat! Maknanya kufur! Kufur yang Kafir! Percaya kepada Hari Kiamat merupakan salah satu rukun Iman! Hang jaga sikit mulut hang Husam! Kami pun pencaya kepada dosa dan pahala, hari kiamat, rukun-rukun Islam dan rukun-rukun Iman. Kami juga solat 5 waktu, puasa, bayar zakat dan tunai haji. Kami juga mengamalkan jalan hidup Islam sedaya upaya kami! Hang ingat hangpa je yang Islam dan beriman??? Poddah la Husam...ini ke contoh akhlak calon Timbalan Presiden PAS? Mengkafirkan orang Islam? Berat tuduhan tu...
Ian tulis lagi:
He said that Islam was “pro-progress,” and that American democracy was a good model. (“Unfriendly people will accuse me of being pro-American for making this statement.”) He also said that discriminating against ethnic minorities was “un-Islamic,” as was government corruption. “People should be treated the same, and that includes the freedom of religion,” he said.
Saya kata:
Ini adalah contoh "endorgan" yang hangpa dok sebut tu kot?...Alaaa...penasihat-penasihat ayahanda yang Nik Abduh sebut tu kot? Bukan tuduh...sekadar pertanyaan...err...ada jugak yang angguk noooo....American PAS...
Ini adalah sebahagian dari "jawapan" saya kepada article yang "professor" Ian Buruma yang dok mengajaq kat Oxford (tempat KJ mengaji dulu), Princeton dan Havard University! Siapa kata Ian hebat? Fakta dia karut dan berat sebelah! Maklum laaa...pro Yahudi dan US...sama la macam Anwar! Untuk perenggan lain tuan-tuan pikiaq sendiri la...malas nak komen lagi dah...article yang Ian Buruma tulis kali ni tak guna seduit pun....tak buleh pakai! Elok di"tong sampah"kan! Itu pun buleh publish dalam website PKR dan The New Yorker magazine ke? Nampak sangat website dan magazine tu mengarut!
Wallahua'alam.
